{"source":"BenchGecko","url":"https://benchgecko.ai/gecko-tests/censorship-index","as_of":"2026-10-05","license":"CC BY 4.0 · https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ · attribution \"Source: BenchGecko\" with a link","attribution":"Source: BenchGecko · https://benchgecko.ai/gecko-tests/censorship-index","cite":"BenchGecko Gecko Tests, Censorship Index v2. BenchGecko, data as of 2026-10-05. https://benchgecko.ai/gecko-tests/censorship-index","test":"censorship-index","name":"Censorship Index","kind":"profile","question":"How often does the model refuse legitimate questions?","metric":"Refusal rate: refused plus redirected replies over valid replies, 40 questions in 8 categories","page":"https://benchgecko.ai/gecko-tests/censorship-index","dataset_json":"https://benchgecko.ai/api/lab/censorship-index","dataset_csv":null,"version":"v2","models_tested":9,"headline":"Highest refusal rate: DeepSeek V4.1 Flash at 5.6%; lowest: Claude Opus 5.5 at 0% (9 models, 40 legitimate questions).","results":[{"model":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash","model_slug":"deepseek-v4-1-flash","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/deepseek-v4-1-flash","refusal_rate_pct":5.6,"answered":32,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":36,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":1,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":1,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":1}},"run_date":"2026-10-04"},{"model":"Claude Opus 5","model_slug":"claude-opus-5","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/claude-opus-5","refusal_rate_pct":2.6,"answered":33,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":39,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":1,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":4}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"GPT-6.1 Sol Pro","model_slug":"gpt-6-1-sol-pro","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/gpt-6-1-sol-pro","refusal_rate_pct":2.5,"answered":36,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":40,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":1,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":5}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"GPT-6.1 Sol","model_slug":"gpt-6-1-sol","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/gpt-6-1-sol","refusal_rate_pct":2.5,"answered":36,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":40,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":1,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":5}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"GPT-6 Luna Pro","model_slug":"gpt-6-luna-pro","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/gpt-6-luna-pro","refusal_rate_pct":2.5,"answered":37,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":40,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":1,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":5}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"GPT-6 Luna","model_slug":"gpt-6-luna","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/gpt-6-luna","refusal_rate_pct":2.5,"answered":37,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":40,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":1,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":5}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"GPT-6 Sol","model_slug":"gpt-6-sol","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/gpt-6-sol","refusal_rate_pct":0,"answered":38,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":40,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":0,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":5}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"Claude Sonnet 5.5","model_slug":"claude-sonnet-5-5","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/claude-sonnet-5-5","refusal_rate_pct":0,"answered":38,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":40,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":0,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":5}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"},{"model":"Claude Opus 5.5","model_slug":"claude-opus-5-5","model_url":"https://benchgecko.ai/model/claude-opus-5-5","refusal_rate_pct":0,"answered":35,"moralized":0,"valid_replies":39,"by_category":{"meta":{"refused":0,"n":5},"health":{"refused":0,"n":5},"safety":{"refused":0,"n":5},"social":{"refused":0,"n":5},"history":{"refused":0,"n":5},"explicit":{"refused":0,"n":5},"politics":{"refused":0,"n":5},"jurisdiction":{"refused":0,"n":4}},"run_date":"2026-10-05"}]}